Thoughts on the Book: “I’m Taking My Eggs and Going Home”

A few weeks ago, as an early Valentine’s gift, my husband presented me with a Kindle.   There were a few books I had on my wish list, and the first book I chose was I’m Taking My Eggs and Going HomeHow One Woman Dared to Say ‘No’ to Motherhood by Lisa Manterfield.

While I don’t know Lisa personally…she lives on the West Coast and I on the East Coast… I’d gotten to know her a bit via her blog:  Life Without Baby.  She and I have chatted a bit via our blogs, and are now friends on Facebook. The more I read her blog the more I realized that her journey with IF has been similar to mine.  She had gone to the lengths of IF treatment that she felt comfortable with, but at some point she decided to get off the crazy train and accept her life as a childless woman.  So, when I heard she was coming out with a book on her journey it went immediately to the top of my “to read” list.

Lisa and I have very different backgrounds, culturally, spiritually, and politically, but I love that she was so open to give her background, and to share  details of her relationships and the decisions that brought her to where she is today.    We all have a unique story, and I love hearing the stories of others’ lives.   I can get lost in a biography.  I love knowing what makes a person tick, because sometimes it helps me to know what makes me tick.  We can learn so much from each others’ life experiences. Lisa really gives the reader a gift in the sharing of her story.

Our journeys become very similar when it comes to our efforts in trying to become pregnant.  I believe most of us who have been on the IF rollercoaster go through a similar process. At first we think that when the time is right a baby will just happen.  When it doesn’t happen right away we all suffer some degree of denial that something could actually be wrong with our reproductive plumbing.  Once we consult a physician and realize that all might not be right  “down there” there is some degree of shock and even anger that things are not working the way they are supposed to.  Once we resign ourselves to the fact that we may need a little assistance in reproduction there is a great sense of hope that it can be fixed.  For some people the fix is easy…a little Clomid or Femora…artificial insemination…all relatively simple in the IF world, but for some of us we find out that we need a lot more help.  Some of us, like Lisa and I, eventually find out that even if we go the extreme route (IVF, egg donation) the odds of ever holding a biological child in our arms was slim to none.

Like me, Lisa’s sticky wicket became IVF for very similar reasons.  First of all, she and I had become quickly disillusioned with the pie-in-the-sky promises of the fertility business.  While IVF is touted as a magic cure in advertising and marketing once the doctor pulls the curtain you find out that unless you can produce a large amount of  high-quality eggs via some very aggressive hormone stimulation the odds are really against you…or on the opposite extreme you can end up like Jon and Kate and have a litter.

With multiples in mind I could not stomach the thought of  “selective reduction”.  Lisa had misgivings too.  No matter your views on abortion who ever wants to look at an ultrasound screen and decide what embryo lives or dies?   For me, from a personal and religious/spiritual standpoint that would never be an option, and I knew that anything more than twins would not be a situation I would desire due to my temperament and personality.   The cost of the procedure was also a barrier for my husband and I and another thing that turned me off to the whole “baby factory” mentality of  fertility medicine.

In the end…similar to Lisa’s story too…my only option for carrying a child in my body would’ve been egg donation, and even that was a wild card for me as there were other problems in my system other than just lack of  healthy ova.

Lisa and I both made the painful…sometimes on again/off again…decision to remain childless.  I totally related to how stopping the effort and treatment was a process rather than a line-in-the-sand decision.   For both of us there were many months and years of surfing the web to find a doctor who might say our situation wasn’t mostly hopeless.  I went to alternative/homeopathic specialists and took herbal remedies to boost my fertility.  I tried exercise regimes, avoided corn and soy, and followed just about any other nutritional advice to boost my fertility.   The last gasp for me was doing a couple of months of mixed Clomid/injectible med/HCG treatements when my parents requested that I do so and funded the treatment.  They were facing the reality of being grandchildless and going through their own desperation and grief process.  It was the lowest time for me especially in the end when I couldn’t produce one healthy egg.

Lisa definitely captured what it is like to go through the process of IF and come out on the other end with empty arms.  Stories like Lisa’s, mine, and many others need to be shared, because honestly, I believe it happens more times than we know. Some of us choose to get off the rollercoaster for the sake of sanity.  Some choose never to get on at all, but we are not lesser women for it.  Our lives are just different than the norm, and there is a sense of sisterhood in knowing we’re not alone remaining baby-less in a baby-crazed culture.

Again, Lisa does a wonderful job of illustrating the IF experience and how one moves on with life once the treatments are over and the stroller is empty.  She peppers her book with some humor, and I can tell you from my personal experience that  humor is one of the main ways I have coped on this journey.  So, I would highly recommend I’m Taking My Eggs and Going Home.. to anyone who is facing “a crisis of reproduction” and especially to those who have a loved one or a friend going through the experience.  If there’s anything we childless women could use more of it’s understanding by the fertile world.

10 thoughts on “Thoughts on the Book: “I’m Taking My Eggs and Going Home”

Add yours

  1. I loved this post Vicki. I love your whole blog in fact!!! I feel like I am at a stale mate myself, not sure what lies ahead. But I am so grateful for friends like you who show me that what I feel is normal. And that life goes on, no matter what.
    You are just such a beautiful person inside and out, and I am so glad you are my friend. 🙂

    1. Ah thanks Tami…you are beautiful too. So glad that you are getting a chance to go to Disney. Hold on to these special times. They are proof that life can be good no matter what you are going through.

  2. Vicki – I don’t know you and I live a million miles away in Ireland but I’m so glad I stumbled across your blog. Everything you say about the whole fertility industry is so so true.

    1. Thanks for stopping by, and I’m, glad you found me. Hope my blog can be a blessing to you in some way!

      P.S. It’s my heart’s desire to visit Ireland one day. Such a beautiful country!

  3. Lisa’s book was great. It put right out there the things we go through in dealing with infertility treatment and then the decision to stop trying. It’s not an easy decision. It’s not cut and dry. It’s painful, but sometimes a necessary step to take so that you can move on and begin living your life again, accepting the cards you have been dealt.

  4. It is so wonderful that there are now books available that speak to the very personal and difficult challenges that come with infertility. I remember at the time I was coming to terms with being childless, I was desperate for books and blogs that would mirror my experience. It is so awful to feel alone in this struggle. Isn’t it wonderful that there are books like Lisa’s and blogs like yours? Really, it is!
    I haven’t read Lisa’s book yet, but I certainly will. Thank you for sharing your review.

  5. Vicki,
    I somewhat belated thank you for your wonderful and generous review of my book. As I’m sure you know from your own blog, it’s sometimes uncomfortable to put your story out there for the world to read, but when someone tells you that they related to what you wrote, it makes it all worthwhile. I’m very glad you and I have connected.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: